I gave my talk/lecture this evening on the Eucharist. I was nervous and highly dubious about it the past few days. I got there early this evening, and while I was still nervous, I wasn’t nearly as nervous as I have been. I hadn’t even practiced the talk. That was really the only thing that made me nervous.
Anyway, I gave the talk (half of it was theology, half of it was my own witness). Well, I took the opportunity to apologize to several people beforehand for being forced to sit through it, because I am not good at giving talks. I thought (still do) I did a mediocre job. I didn’t do poorly, but I didn’t do anything superbly either. That worked for me. I know, I know. Why is a perfectionist content with mediocrity? Well, this perfectionist hates being the center of attention, and she finds that she exudes more confidence and intelligence through writing than speaking. If I don’t shine out in a talk, then I won’t be asked to give one again, right? Of course, it’s such a critical talk, and it is faith formation for people planning on receiving sacraments at Easter, so I couldn’t do a poor job either. I wanted them to get something out of it, but I wasn’t exactly hoping for people to come back asking for more, if you understand my meaning.
When I finished, everyone clapped. I figured it’s common courtesy to clap after someone finishes talking, so ok, whatever. After we were released to our break to get snacks and head off to small groups, I was bombarded by several people. Everyone told me the talk was perfect. The quiet girl in my small group spoke up for maybe the second time this semester and told me she thought it was the best talk of the semester, and she thanked me for that. A catechumen told me that my talk completely inspired and excited her. She said she was so touched and so thankful for my words, and she proceeded to ask me if it would be all right if we could maybe get together some time to talk. An acquaintance’s husband I don’t really know that well came up and pulled me into a hug, telling me what a fantastic job I did. Ok, I thought, this is really weird.
I slipped out and went to my small group that I lead. They all sang me praises while I lit up bright red. I thanked them for their kindness and tried to transition things back to the discussion questions. I answered questions they had for me, and we just talked about the discussion questions. Things went well. We ended our small group time with a closing prayer and then headed back downstairs for final announcements and a group closing prayer.
After the group closing prayer, I was once again assailed on all sides. A fully catechized Catholic came up to me and said that she felt the need to personally thank me for both my talk and my witness. She went on to explain that she had her First Communion when she was in second grade, so she just got used to it and never really perceived it as special. She told me that for a while she stopped receiving Communion at all, but that recently within the past year she started back up and was finally starting to feel something special because of it. She said that my talk really spoke to her and what she’s currently going through, and she said it just really comforted and encouraged her. I was honored and thankful that she shared her story with me, and after getting her name, I gave her a hug. She thanked me again and headed out.
Then the husband of a friend (he has become my friend, too) came over and gave me a hug. He said I did an awesome job and said that he was proud of me. He then told me that I need to come over to their place more often. His wife nodded in agreement and said, “We’ll cook for you!” My oh so eloquent response was, “Hey, I like food.” It seemed better than saying that I was not terribly fond of the hour or so commute to their place. (Of course, it’s worth it to spend time with friends, but such a waste of time if you don’t have a book!) The darling I am sponsoring this year came over for the third or forth time and hugged me tightly and said that my talk was amazing and that she loved it and she loved me and that she felt so lucky to have me as her sponsor. I squeezed her and kissed her cheek, all the while thinking that if anyone was lucky in this deal it is me. Watching her just made my heart swell. She seemed so proud of me. I still don’t understand why, but she seemed touched by the talk and said that it made her even more excited than she already is. I guess that’s all that matters.
Several people I don’t even know came up and thanked me for the talk. As an afterthought they congratulated me for a job well done. Several hugged me, and again told me how deeply I touched them and how no book could have conveyed what I said or excited them the way I did. Then I started wondering, what exactly did I say in my talk? Did I give them the answer to life? Did I impart some great wisdom? Crap. I missed my own revelations! Oh, wait, Br. Sam’s got it on tape. A couple of girls from my small group told me that the apology was completely unnecessary. I had to think for a minute before I realized that they were talking about my apology before I gave the talk, because I was convinced it was going to be horrible. That made me blush.
Finally, everyone started heading out. After the class, the leadership team (myself, two other individuals and Br. Sam) meet to discuss how things went in small group and in class and to address any questions or issues. So, we all met for a little huddle. My fellow leadership team members again told me what a wonderful job I did, and I finally expressed my confusion. I told them that I didn’t understand why everyone was hailing my talk and witness, because I simply thought it mediocre. I didn’t think I did that great of a job. Even if I did do well, I certainly didn’t do well enough to warrant the kind of reception I’d been getting. They looked at me and said, “Yeah, that’s just you, because everyone else thought you did a fantastic job!” Br. Sam looked at me and said, “Lindsay, it was perfect. The way you strung it all together–you asked them questions and involved them, you had Biblical excerpts, you had excerpts of tradition to show how little has changed, you explained all the theology in an easy to understand manner, and then your witness–wow, your witness. Oh, and, no pressure or anything, but I expect your next talk to be even better since this was your first time.” He winked and laughed at the last part, then he said, “I don’t mean to scare you, but I think we’ve found your calling.” I just quipped back, “Uh, I think that’d require me to get an entirely different MA.” He thought about it for a second and said, “Nah. We just need to find you a diocese that doesn’t require them.” Then someone said, “Seriously, your first time… that was phenomenal.” By this point, I imagine I was a shade of red that cannot be described. Fortunately for me, the group huddle was over and I was free to leave.
Except then I was ambushed by even more people on the sidewalk saying goodbye who hadn’t talked to me yet. I hurried out of there as soon as I could. I wanted to do a good job, but I didn’t want to do that well. I wasn’t even trying to! Then I realized that God has a sick sense of humor. He knows I hate giving talks. He knows I hate being the center of attention. He knew how to completely freak me out, and He succeeded. I had wanted things to go well. I just hadn’t expected things to go this well. I’m just me, after all. I’m nobody special. The entire walk back to my room all I could think about were Br. Sam’s words and everything else everyone said to me, and, to be completely honest, it terrifies me. If I were to talk to Br. Sam about it, he’d say, “Yeah, well, I didn’t want to be Catholic, much less a brother, and look at where that got me. I don’t even like going to Mass!” Where, indeed.
